The original post: /r/datahoarder by /u/theswedishguy94 on 2025-01-22 20:43:11.

Documentary filmmaker here. Following advice from this sub regarding my 10TB+ of work files, I opted against LTO and purchased two 18TB Seagate Evo X NAS drives (refurbished, 219€ each) instead of a full NAS setup due to budget constraints.

Current situation:

  • Two 18TB drives

  • Single apartment room

  • Limited budget

  • Main workstation PC

Proposed setup until I can afford a proper NAS:

  1. One drive constantly connected to my PC (warm storage)
  2. Second drive as cold backup, only connected during backup operations
  3. Both drives physically stored in my PC case

My reasoning:

  • Cold backup drive protected from malware/cyber threats when disconnected

  • Similar physical security whether stored in PC or nearby drawer

  • PC can act as makeshift NAS for network transfers from laptop

  • Cost-effective intermediate solution

Questions:

  1. Any recommended software for checking drive health on arrival?
  2. Is this a reasonable temporary solution?
  3. Anything crucial I’m overlooking?

Long-term goals include proper 3-2-1 backup (2 local + 1 cloud), but need to work within current budget constraints.

Appreciate any feedback on this approach!