Which? claims firm engaged in anti-competitive practices that led to 40 million people ‘being overcharged’

Apple is facing a near-£3bn lawsuit over claims it breached competition law by effectively locking millions of UK consumers into its cloud storage service at “rip-off” prices.

  • Darth_MewEnglish
    6•1 month ago

    I don’t get it either, what does perceived affordability have to do with a “monopoly”?

    • warm
      19•1 month ago

      It’s not the price that is the problem, it’s how iCloud is integrated into the device, in a way Apple don’t allow other cloud services to do. iCloud has access other apps simply do not, so they cannot compete fairly.

      • astrsk
        -8•1 month ago

        What? You can host your own nextcloud instance and use it in the files app as a storage location and have all the same “save to” and “Read from” actions for documents that iCloud has. I use that and smb shares regularly and the only apps that don’t work with it are the ones who choose not to implement the apis for it. How is it monopolistic if Apple’s 1st party apps and software only work with their 1st party storage offering while allowing anyone to use the system api’s to connect and access any other storage service they want? Is it just them complaining that you can’t backup photos to anything but iCloud (except you can, by plugging it into any computer locally)? I really don’t understand, legitimately.

        • RomkslrquszEnglish
          11•1 month ago

          except you can, by plugging it into a computer locally

          That’s not even remotely close to being the same as the experience iCloud offers.

          • astrsk
            -2•1 month ago

            So don’t use iCloud and the photos app? What’s the problem here? There are plenty of third party camera apps and photo managers that could all use the same apis to access your directly integrated nextcloud storage the same way the photos app works. Hell, Plex offers automatic photo backups to your plex server! Y’all need to actually explain what this monopoly claim is in better detail. What am I not understanding here?

            • Darth_MewEnglish
              2•1 month ago

              not everyone is a pc geek with self hosted services numbnuts. you’re annoying as hell

            • RomkslrquszEnglish
              1•1 month ago

              Third party apps don’t have the ability to back up in the background all the time the way the native Photos / iCloud experience does. They need to be periodically opened to have temporary background access.

              Launching the third party camera app cannot be done from the lockscreen.

              What you’re not understanding is the entire point of folks’ complaints. With arbitrary restrictions put in place by Apple, there cannot be full parity in functionality between Apple’s native apps / cloud experience and those that can delivered by third party apps. While it’s possible to use third party apps, there are a bunch of little quirks and inconveniences that will ultimately drive the user back towards the native apps and spending money on Apple’s cloud service.

              • GHiLAEnglish
                0•1 month ago

                Who’s forcing them to buy an iPhone?

                I mean, at some point you might want to pull the problem up by the root. The root seems to be Apple.

        • @[email protected]English
          4•1 month ago

          Having to regularly plug your phone into a PC to back up 100GB+ of photos and videos over a USB 2 connection is not even remotely the same as automatic backups to iCloud that you can then access instantly, at any time, anywhere.